Close Menu
The Watch
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    The Watch
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • Top Stories
      • USNORTHCOM
      • Homeland Defense
      • Chinese Communist Party (CCP)
      • Russia
    • USNORTHCOM AOR
      • Arctic
      • North America
      • Mexico
      • The Caribbean
    • eTalk/Panel
      • Arctic eTalks
      • Arctic Academic eTalks
      • RUSI NS Panels
      • Perry Center eTalks/Panels
      • Ted Stevens Center eTalks/Panels
    • ASFR
    • Journal
      1. Enduring Partnerships – V6
      2. Mutually Beneficial Trusted Partnerships
      3. Regional Cooperation
      4. U.S. Shares Military Capabilities
      5. Special Reports
      6. Archive
      7. View All

      Fuerzas Amigas

      July 24, 2025

      Operation Amalgam Eagle

      July 24, 2025

      Mexico’s Cyber Force

      July 24, 2025

      Advancing Arctic Collaboration

      July 24, 2025

      Strengthening the Sweden-U.S. Partnership

      July 24, 2025

      Nordic Vision 2030

      July 24, 2025

      Countering CCP Presence

      July 24, 2025

      Defending the North American Arctic

      July 24, 2025

      Guardians of the Arctic

      July 24, 2025

      WHINSEC Supports Homeland Defense

      July 24, 2025

      Advancing Arctic Collaboration

      July 24, 2025

      Maritime Muscle

      July 24, 2025

      Mexico’s Cyber Force

      July 24, 2025

      Fuerzas Amigas

      July 24, 2025

      Operation Amalgam Eagle

      July 24, 2025

      Operation Fenix

      July 24, 2025

      Eyeing Arctic dominance, U.S. bill earmarks $8.6 billion for icebreakers

      August 5, 2025

      Denmark begins drafting women as Russian threat looms

      August 4, 2025

      NATO steps up air presence along northeastern flank

      August 1, 2025

      Turks and Caicos police intercept 194 migrants

      August 1, 2025

      Eyeing Arctic dominance, U.S. bill earmarks $8.6 billion for icebreakers

      August 5, 2025

      Denmark begins drafting women as Russian threat looms

      August 4, 2025

      NATO steps up air presence along northeastern flank

      August 1, 2025

      Turks and Caicos police intercept 194 migrants

      August 1, 2025

      Eyeing Arctic dominance, U.S. bill earmarks $8.6 billion for icebreakers

      August 5, 2025

      Denmark begins drafting women as Russian threat looms

      August 4, 2025

      NATO steps up air presence along northeastern flank

      August 1, 2025

      Turks and Caicos police intercept 194 migrants

      August 1, 2025
    • About Us
      • Contributors
    • Contact Us
    The Watch
    Home » China’s Arctic ambitions tempered by geographic realities
    180315-N-KC128-215 Ice Camp Skate (March 15, 2018) – A view from Ice Camp Skate in the Arctic Circle in support of Ice Exercise (ICEX) 2018, March 15. ICEX 2018 is a five-week exercise that allows the Navy to assess its operational readiness in the Arctic, increase experience in the region, advance understanding of the Arctic environment, and continue to develop relationships with other services, allies and partner organizations. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Daniel Hinton)
    Top Stories

    China’s Arctic ambitions tempered by geographic realities

    The WatchBy The WatchNovember 1, 2021Updated:November 1, 2021No Comments3 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    THE WATCH STAFF

    China presumptuously declared itself to be a “near-Arctic state” in a 2018 white paper, raising concerns about its ambitions in the region that have only intensified.

    Recent history suggests those concerns are warranted: Beijing’s broad claims to maritime rights have led to disputes in the South China Sea, and it has sought greater global influence through its One Belt, One Road infrastructure scheme.

    Still, one scholar says that China’s goals in the Arctic may be more nuanced than its conduct in the Indo-Pacific and elsewhere, given what he calls “two very inconvenient truths.”

    “First of all, China’s a newcomer to the Arctic,” said Dr. Marc Lanteigne, an associate professor of political science at The Arctic University of Norway, Tromso (UiT). “It is still trying to … understand many different aspects of Arctic life on the local level, on the subregional level. And this is a process which takes time. It’s not something that can be bought.

    “And the second inconvenient truth is that China is not an Arctic state.”

    Lanteigne spoke during an October 21, 2021, online panel discussion titled “China and the Arctic: great power competition, security and regional responses” presented by LSE IDEAS, the foreign policy think tank of the London School of Economics and Political Science, and UiT.

    For those reasons, Lanteigne said, China must tread carefully in the region and is “very dependent on the goodwill of the Arctic states for much of its policies.”

    The eight Arctic sovereign states are Canada, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the United States. Those nations make up the Arctic Council (AC). China is one of several AC “observer” states.

    The Arctic may seem an unusual priority for China, given that its northernmost point is still more than 900 miles from the Arctic Circle. (Pictured: A 2018 view from the Arctic Circle.) Still, as others in the panel discussion pointed out, the Arctic order historically has reflected the international order of the day.

    Lanteigne said that China’s agenda focuses on three areas:

    • Science: Beijing wants to develop partnerships — “scientific diplomacy” — to help it understand how climate change in the Arctic is affecting its weather and environment. Lanteigne noted that one concern is “dual use” — scientific pursuits and data put to work for military purposes.
    • Economy: With climate change making the region’s oil, natural gas and minerals more accessible, China sees potential for infrastructure development and doesn’t want to be left out. It already has envisioned projects that haven’t panned out because of pushback from Arctic nations.
    • Governance: Will Beijing remain content with its observer status? Lanteigne envisions a future — say in 10 years after China has more investment in the region — when it begins to “push against the boundaries a bit to say: ‘OK, we’d like a little bit more of a say in Arctic affairs.’”

    Still, given that focus, Lanteigne remained skeptical that China seeks militarization in the region because of its dependence on Russia and other Arctic states for much of its policies.

    “So, when we talk about Arctic security, it is really, really important, first of all, to look at what is happening versus what might happen because these two very often get confused,” Lanteigne said.

    “That said, China is an … emerging Arctic player. And it’s only a question of what is the trajectory of China’s role in the region.”

    IMAGE CREDIT: PETTY OFFICER 1ST CLASS DANIEL HINTON/U.S. NAVY

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Related Posts

    Canada’s three new River-class warships mark start of fleet overhaul

    August 14, 2024

    Opinion: Trilateral cooperation needed to combat North America’s fentanyl epidemic

    August 14, 2024

    NATO allies Denmark, Norway announce drone collaboration

    August 14, 2024

    Comments are closed.

    V6. ENDURING PARTNERSHIPS
    V6. INSERT

    Subscribe and download the latest issue

    The Watch is provided FREE to military and security professionals.

    The Watch
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    © 2025 The Watch.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.